(Many nurses and doctors in our Facebook group pump using the Willow because they are able to bend over and care for patients while pumping.). I LOVE the Kindred Bravely Sublime pumping and nursing bra. My own personal insurance let me purchase the pump, then submit paperwork to get reimbursed for their breast pump allotment, which came out to be about half of the cost of the pump. Elvie offers a two year warranty on the pump and 90 days on the pump parts. Since I tried out BOTH of the two most popular options on the market last year (the Willow Pump and the Elvie Pump) while I nursed my fourth baby Harry, I figured I should sit down and chat with my besties about which one I liked best. Both the Elvie and Willow work best when all the parts are dry, so the extra drying time afforded by the second set of parts was helpful. If you're using the proprietary Willow storage bags, you can buy them directly from the company for $23.99 for a package of 48. Plus, many insurances will at least partially cover the cost. I went directly from using my traditional pump to the Elvie and found no difference in output. What's going on? Wearing the Elvie didn't feel nearly secure enough to try exercise or significant moving around while pumping. Admittedlythe shirt I was wearingin these pictures was a little more fitted than Im comfortable with when Im usingthe Willow Pump, so I highly recommend wearing a very loose button-down or zip hoodie or house dress and it will be even more discreet. I found the Elvie incredibly easy to useyou attach the breast shield to the Hub (the main electric part of the pump), then snap the base milk container in. Check with your own insurance plan before buying the Elvie or Willow. They arent connected at all and can work independently you can pump on one side or both sides using these pumps. 24mm and 27mm, with inserts for 17mm, 19mm, and 21mm, Takes about 2 hours to charge; charge lasts for 2.5 hours of pumping, Takes about 2 hours to charge; charge lasts for about 5 pumping sessions, Takes 2 hours to charge, lasts for about an hour, Support via call or text during business hours, One year from purchase date; 90 days on pump parts. There are some hands-free breast pumps that are not wireless, such as the Freemie Liberty (it fits in your bra but does have tubing and an external pump motor), but this article focuses on the best wireless breast pumps. Every mama is different, so finding the pump that works best with your lifestyle is a must! 2021 TrulyMama.com All rights reserved. Willows warranty is one year from purchase, and they also cover the accessories for 90 days. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. The total 5-ounce capacity was enough to hold an entire pumping session's worth of breast milk. Learn how your comment data is processed. YES! The main drawback I had with the pump is that it can be a challenge to clean. Neil preferred helping me assemble the Elvie for this reason alone! But youll have to use a separate bag to store or freeze milk. Here's what I chose. WILLOW: The Willow pump storage bags and reusable Milk Container hold up to 4 oz. Scientists discover ancient shark swimming in a really strange place, 'Wordle' today: Here's the answer, hints for August 1, B.J. For me, losing my liquid gold was a deal-breaker. It all comes down to the features that work best for you. To my surprise, despite how much more comfortable it was, I didnt experience any decrease in my milk supply. Giving my baby breast milk was a priority to me and because I was able to get my pump partially covered by insurance, it was much more affordable than buying formula would have been. ELVIE: This pump uses bottles that are dishwasher safe so yes, that part can be reused! This distinction matters because it affects what kind of milk storage you might prefer. This website is for educational purposes and should not be considered medical advice. Elvies app also allows you to control the pump. All Rights Reserved. The Elvie breast pump is a wearable, hands free, and completely wireless breast pump that has revolutionized the pumping game. (If you buy a double pump, the Elvie comes with two charging cords.). WILLOW: The Willow Pump takes about two hours to fully charge. Uncontrolled space junk is a big problem. It honestly depends on WHY you want this pump. of milk on each side. Best Hands Free Breast Pump: Elvie vs Willow vs Momcozy (2022), Willow Pump Review Hands-free Pumping (2022), Best Portable Breast Pumps (2022 Reviews) , you can read more about the Willow Go here, the others are available separately from the website. For full-time or exclusively pumping moms, it can give a freedom like never seen before. In contrast, the Elvie's milk bottle is underneath the motor and visible from the outside, though your bra will be covering it while you pump. Hi, Im Corrine and its pretty simple. The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox. When you pump using the Willow, you can pump into. How much you will be able to produce as a pumping mom will varyaccording to a 2015 study that looked at pumping moms vs. nursing-at-the-breast parents, the same amount of milk was produced. So for that reason, theyre extremely similar. Session 2: Pump with bottles 3 and 4, then combine it all into bottle 3 and wash bottle 4. This hands-free breast pumphas literally been a complete and total GAME CHANGER for me. Compared to the Willow, it was also a bit easier to assemble IF you didnt know how to assemble the Willow. Each is eligible to be purchased with money from a health savings account (HSA) or a flexible spending account (FSA). Choosing which pump will be right for you. (Idaho Jones makes a great case for wearable pumps as well as a special backpack that you can use to take your pump on the go. Thanks for signing up. While it is an investment, the pump is covered by some insurances (check with yours to confirm) and is HSA and FSA eligible. Read More. It was somewhere around 3 AM, in my second pumping session of the night, when the baby was screaming, I was stuck in the chair with a machine mechanically removing milk from my breasts, and my husband was stumbling to the kitchen to fix another bottle, when I realized something: After my daughter was born a bit prematurely and spent a week in the NICU, it soon became apparent that at-the-breast feeding was not going to work for us. and I went from being confused to totally confident in how to use mine after one video call. WILLOW: If the special bags are a concern to you, you can now buyreusable milk containersthat can be drained right into a storage bag OR a bottle. Because I had a large milk supply, I decided to go with the Elvie. The Willow does have an option to buy a reusable plastic milk container that attaches to the pump. I was an EP mom with a decision to make: should I buy the Elvie or the Willow? I tried once and was very unsuccessful haha. A Pain in the Boob: Clogged Milk Ducts and How to Clear Them. The Willow also costs $499 and comes with 24 of the company's proprietary bags. It depends on your insurance plan. They can be washed by hand or on the top shelf of the dishwasher. The Elvie comes with two sizes of flanges in the box. The milk containers are sold separately, and cost an additional $50, and require additional steps to secure into the pump. Willow recommends not using a microwave sterilizer bag to sterilize their pump parts. For me, I reasoned that it was still far less than purchasing formula and because giving my baby my breast milk was incredibly important to me as a mom, I felt that it was well worth the money. As a self-proclaimed (and industry recognized!) This is the first point of differentiation between the Willow and Elvie. You can always get the second pump later if you love it. -Kourtney, Your email address will not be published. My other hesitation with the Willow vs the Elvie was that the Willow has specific milk bags that you have to buy, so you cant use any normal type of milk bags in it. WILLOW: This pump is not necessarily advertised as hospital grade, but from their website they say, Willow has seven levels of suction in Expression phase that are comparable to most traditional double electric and hospital-grade. This post refers to the Willow 3.0, but you can read more about the Willow Go here.). There are now a few wireless breast pumps on the market, and its hard to know which to choose Elvie vs Willow vs Momcozy. Both the Elvie and Willow are single-user pumps and cannot be shared. Aeroflow Breastpumps stocks both the Elvie and the Willow, and you may be able to get it at a discounted price through them. Pump parts should be completely dry before using again. Lets take a look at the Elvie vs. the Willow and break down the differences between the two. The Momcozy pump lasts about an hour and takes 2 to fully charge. This type of pump allows for greater mobility than standard breast pumps that need to be plugged into a wall and have long tubes connecting the flanges to the motor. However, SOME bags may come in handy, as they are spill-proof. Chaunie Brusie is a mom of five and a registered nurse turned writer, editor, and author. While the Willow does advertise that you can lay down to pump, personally, I always felt more comfortable remaining upright. I decided it was time to look for a hands free breast pump. Many moms pump a stash of milk prior to returning to work and freeze it. If you're pumping with the Elvie, or the Willow's reusable milk container, you can store breast milk in freezer bags, which are available at most stores from brands like Lansinoh or Medela. Your email address will not be published. One of the bigger differences is what you pump into: If you pump more than the bag or bottle holds, the Elvie and Willow will automatically stop to allow you to change out the bag or bottle, so you dont have to worry about overflowing. However, exactly what type of pump that a policy covers can vary a lot. Elvie vs. Willow: Which Hands Free Breast Pump Is Right for You? This pump also made our goal of going on weekly temple dates so much more doable. So a three session day might look like this: Session 1: Pump with bottles 1 and 2, then combine it all into bottle 1 and wash bottle 2. WILLOW: Yes it is easy to clean and the parts are all dishwasher safe! Did one have better suction then the other? Unfortunately, you cannot return either pump once theyve been opened. Buy the Elvie Hands Free Breast Pump Today, Fits completely in your bra or nursing shirt, Charge lasts about 2.5 hours, depending on intensity setting, 3 breast shield sizes (24 and 28 mm are included, 21 mm can be purchased separately), Can be controlled via free and secure app, Washable parts are BPA-free and dishwasher-safe, 2-year warranty on the Hub, 90 days on washable parts, Can be used with reusable milk containers or insertable milk bags, Can be operated manually or through free app, Battery lasts up to 5 pumping sessions, and takes 2 hours to fully charge. I havent used either since Im a new momma to be, but this was so helpful to see some pros and cons! And every time I attempted this, I inevitably spilled some milk, or lost some precious teaspoons when it got inevitably trapped in the tubing. Stress has been found to play a role in inhibiting breastfeeding, so nursing parents are often told to try to relax when feeding their babies or pumping. I tried the Elive Pump with Harry and was genuinely so excited to be able to compare both! Pumping went from a dreaded chore that left me crazed trying to keep the baby happy on my own to something I could easily do while still holding or feeding her, or getting stuff done around the house. Two Momcozy pumps are about $120. The Elvie Pump was also a more desirable option initially because you could use dishwasher-safe bottles to catch the milk instead of the made-for-Willow bags that were the only option when the Willow was first created. When I very first got my Willow Pump with Millie, I was frustrated the first time or two of trying to figure it out. You can get 10% off with the code EPUMP.). I seriously dont think you can go wrong with either one. I would pump right before we went to the temple, on our way in the car, and then if it was a longer session, I could pump on our way home, too! The Momcozy is a little more conspicuous because the motor and battery hub is on top of the collection cups outside the bra. Im officially a hands free breast pump convert, and I tell every mom I can that if you are pumping for any regular time, a wireless pump is definitely worth the investment. Below are the major differences between the Willow, Elvie, and Momcozy pumps at a glance. Some insurance plans will cover the cost of a breast pump, while others will outline which type you have to buy. ELVIE: Probably even slightly easier to clean and definitely also dishwasher safe. Thanks to a one-way valve, you also can't spill it at this stage. For me personally, I found that initially, I produced too much for my babypumping around the clock to establish a supply meant that my body didnt ever adjust to what my baby needed naturally, so I did have to do some trial and error with my pumping schedule. You can review Willows sizing chart here, Elvies here, and Momcozys here. It can be used with disposable milk bags that fit directly into the pump or with reusable milk containers that you fit directly into the pump. Truly Mama's Elvie pump users swear the pump changed their lives for the better and allowed them to pump full-time just when they were about to give up. Wearing a snug bra keeps the Willow secure enough to do yoga or other moderate-intensity activities, even where the pump becomes inverted or when the user is lying down. THANK YOU! I also have to give a plug to the Willow Support team. Hands free breast pumps can offer new moms amazing freedom! If youre exclusively pumping and decide to get a Willow, I would recommend buying the reusable milk container, as just using the bags will get expensive. No deals right now, but we are always keeping an eye out! The 24 mm flange comes with the pump; the others are available separately from the website. It also promised to be quieter, and that promise was definitely delivered!! I found it easier to use, but that could be because I was already used to it from having used it so much with Millie? The Elvie can handle a greater volume of milk produced in a session 5 ounces compared to 4 ounces for the Willow. So those are the differences between the Elvie,Willow, and Momcozy which do you think is the best hands free breast pump currently on the market? There are absolutely cheaper ways to pump in a car (like this handheld pump!) Choosing Joy: What You See is What You Get. Short answer: I tried both theWillowandElvie Breast Pumpwith Harry and while I think theyre both good pumps, I have to say that I used myWillow pumpway more. My baby is 6 months and Ive been battling trying to find a good suction, and quite, doesnt need to be silent, just good enough for public.. and its hard! Top Nordstrom Anniversary Sale KIDS picks! Both the pump motor and the milk collection units are housed within the shell that fits in your bra, so pumping is completely convenient and 100% hands free. With the investment the same, my choice came down to what I wanted out of a hands free breast pump. Because of the Elvie, I was able to exclusively pump for 6 months, then continue pumping with supplementing formula for my baby for almost an entire year. It's battery-powered, rechargeable, and easy-to-use and operate. Not all wireless pumps are created equal. Elvies pump parts can be sterilized using boiling water, a microwave steam bag, or the dishwasher. It made breast feeding through bottle feeding possible for me, and that was super important to me as a mom, so Im incredibly grateful I found this product. Spoilers within. Stuck on 'Wordle' #409? "It was just a private joke, which is even more pure.". How I do back to school clothes shopping as a mom of 4. Long answer: Theyre extremely comparable and I really think you cant go wrong with either one. Our reviewer found this took a bit of practice, and she accidentally dumped milk all over her counter the first time she did it. I also loved that the suction could be changed on the actual pump instead of only on the app. The Elvie (left) and Willow are cordless, rechargeable breast pumps that fit inside a nursing bra. I loved the convenience, and found assembling the pump very easyI could quite literally grab and go to pump throughout the day. Momcozy offers phone (1-855-322-1777) and email (support@momcozy.com) support. Right off the bat, I chose the Elvie vs. the Willow because the Elvie will hold a total of 10 ounces of milk at a time, while the Willow will only hold 8 ounces. The Elvie took a huge amount of stress off of me during pumping sessions, so I definitely saw that reflected in how my milk letdown and milk supply fared. And when my husband had to go back to work, and I was left alone to get my other 4 school-aged children out the door and to school every morning, and care for the baby, I soon realized I would need some help if I wanted to continue pumping. In fact, for me, the Elvie was far more comfortable to use, so I actually had an increase in output because I wasnt as tense while pumping. Elvie offers support via email (questions@elvie.com). Share on Facebook (opens in a new window), Share on Flipboard (opens in a new window). Even with working from home, I found a wearable pump EXTREMELY helpful if I really needed to be totally tuned-into a meeting instead of distracted by trying to feed my baby. I did this every week or so for a deep clean, and then all washable parts could just be thrown right in the dishwasher. Each insurance company has its own policy regarding reimbursement for breast pumps, so once you have your pump, the next step is to check with your plan administrator to see what you qualify for. Game changer. To learn more click here. Novak breaks down the strange lie Mindy Kaling told him on the set of 'The Office'. Mashable, MashBash and Mashable House are among the federally registered trademarks of Ziff Davis, LLC and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission. More info here. In fact, when you buy a double pump, you are actually buying TWO pumps, one for each breast. The only problem? I feel like it gave me both my sanity back and my wish to provide my daughter with breast milk. That said, I had used the Willow with Millie to pump here and there for 8 months, so by the time I compared the two, I could assemble the Willow and pump bag in my sleep! I also used my wearable pump when I traveled away from home and, like I mentioned before, I took it with me to work conferences when Millie was 6-8 months old if I needed to pump to keep my supply while I was away from her, and it was infinitely easier than having to pack and carry-on a bigger, more bulky pump. Save or Dump: Can I Feed My Baby This Breast Milk?