corduroy $85.80, $143.00 I have been looking for a new version and recently found this one at J.Crew. You've already signed up for some newsletters, but you haven't confirmed your address. Under Add your personalization, the text box will tell you what the seller needs to know. Ad from shop PaintedJackets4U The Madewell jacket is 1.5 longer than the J. jacket cool jcrew trapper crew short tips jackets utility moss mens clothing clothes must piece why outfit man outerwear jeans CMsVintageshoppe (15% off), ad by DCScoundrels ToBeWornAgain This denim chore jacket fits true to size and its a chic alternative compared to the classic denim jacket. Handbag: Marc by Marc Jacobs I think both denim jackets run small. Fill out the requested information. Ad from shop Gladifoundyou Ad from shop 7thblockdesigns Ad from shop FragilethingsbyJiroo FREE shipping, ad by PinsByFerris DreamboatAnnyVintage We do this with marketing and advertising partners (who may have their own information theyve collected). remembering account, browser, and regional preferences, remembering privacy and security settings, personalized search, content, and recommendations, helping sellers understand their audience, showing relevant, targeted ads on and off Etsy. From shop daisypickers, $45.00 In full disclosure, I will receive a commission for any sales that are made, Serena & Lily Riviera Dining Chair in fog/white | Crate & Barrel Strut 36 glass top table from 2012 (similar) | Small White Storage Baskets (recommend seeing them out in stores since theyre all different. I hope this post is helpful if youre in a similar search! TrueWaveApparel Required fields are marked *. Ad from shop Fabricationss I saw the sweatshirt in store and I didnt love the material plus I also recently bought this puff sleeve sweatshirt (as seen here) and this white sweatshirt anyway. Try contacting them via Messages to find out! jcrew vicars Original Price $143.00 I wouldnt pair the boxy jacket with flare crop jeans but I had to try both of them together to see for myself. Sign up to receive my weekly newsletters with post recaps, sale alerts, and exclusive content just for subscribers! Try using a different browser or disabling ad blockers. $64.00, $80.00 Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. FREE shipping, ad by FloralBanditStudio Shipping policies vary, but many of our sellers offer free shipping when you purchase from them. I also ordered the flare crop jeans in the seton wash and they should arrive soon (the denim wash was on backorder so they shipped later and will arrive next week).   United States   |   English (US)   |   $ (USD). FREE shipping, ad by AirshipVintageCo Etsys 100% renewable electricity commitment includes the electricity used by the data centers that host Etsy.com, the Sell on Etsy app, and the Etsy app, as well as the electricity that powers Etsys global offices and employees working remotely from home in the US. PinsByFerris The Madewell jacket is a medium to light denim shade. From shop AirshipVintageCo, Sale Price $67.19 Original Price $80.00 SparklyLife Looks like you already have an account! 7thblockdesigns From shop MagicCarpetVintageUS, $84.00 chore jcrew duck Sofia Jeans by Sofia Vergara Womens Mid-Rise Shorts, size 00 (review here, similar here and here) | New Balance Womens Dynasoft Pesu V1 Running Shoe (review here) | Click here to view a clip of the outfit on me. These white flare crop jeans fit similar to skinny jeans with a slight kick at the hem. Ad from shop PromotionsGeek bluegrassblondeshop DavidsonStudio I am 52.5 tall and classify myself as petite. Crew jacket is slightly lighter in color and has some distressing to it. I am waiting for the next sale to order the 9 rise for comparison since I would prefer the slightly higher rise for more support. From handmade pieces to vintage treasures ready to be loved again, Etsy is the global marketplace for unique and creative goods. From shop Gladifoundyou, $95.00 distress madewell From shop GreenCanyonTradingCo, ad by 1027dreams Ad from shop slayvin MarilynsClassicStore From shop Fabricationss, ad by HonorStudentVintage From shop BlackPearlVintage, $168.00 FREE shipping. cuteclothesforteens quilted lightweight jcrew I ordered an XS in both jackets from Nordstrom. From shop WildHorseSupplyCo, ad by GetThrifteeStore From shop PromotionsGeek, Sale Price $69.68 RecapVintageStudio document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); What a great weekend outfit! For size reference Im 5 2.5 and 113-115 pounds. $35.99, $39.99 From shop TrueWaveApparel, ad by ShopMannerly Jeans: J.Crew eldowho Choose the options youd like for the order. Absolutely! Since I plan to wear the jacket with the sleeves rolled this wasnt a deciding factor in which jacket that I kept. blazer jacket jcrew campbell gingham crew Sellers looking to grow their business and reach more interested buyers can use Etsys advertising platform to promote their items. blazer parke LorenaCheetahDesigns Size: XS The two pockets on the inside do have a small opening at the bottom corner so I wouldnt use them for anything that could slip out. Dont see this option? Watch: Daniel Wellington. 1027dreams Your email address will not be published. Saying no will not stop you from seeing Etsy ads or impact Etsy's own personalization technologies, but it may make the ads you see less relevant or more repetitive. From shop eldowho, $120.00 Both jackets have 6 pockets, four on the outside (2 hand pockets + 2 chest pockets) and two interior pockets. The seller might still be able to personalize your item. FREE shipping, ad by WildHorseSupplyCo Ad from shop SusOriginals corduroy careofcarl artiklar FREE shipping, ad by Gladifoundyou FREE shipping, ad by FragilethingsbyJiroo My favorite is to pair it with black denim jeans and a white top. From shop 7thblockdesigns, $69.99 From shop LilChickenVintage, ad by CompanyMan Take full advantage of our site features by enabling JavaScript. Original Price $39.99 FREE shipping, $395.00 Send me exclusive offers, unique gift ideas, and personalized tips for shopping and selling on Etsy. Crew Classic Denim Jacket in Light Patriot Wash (style #H5593) The tag has SP19, which indicates its part of the spring 2019 collection. I am typically an XXS in J. From shop ShopMannerly, $175.00 I love the slim fit and classic blue wash. My favorite way to style the denim jacket is layered over my go-to essentials, but I also love it paired with a dressy outfit to make it a little more casual. I also ordered this ivory eyelet ruffle sweatshirt but they sent me an ivory pencil skirt instead. I cant quite put my finger on it, but theres something about the Madewell jacket thats just a tiny bit more comfortable. The jacket rarely looks the same as the stock photo IRL. We also created 2.6 million jobs in the U.S.enough to employ the entire city of Houston, TX! $153.00, $180.00 $69.68, $81.98 lyst Ad from shop RecapVintageStudio FREE shipping, $15.00 Etsy is powered by 100% renewable electricity. Ad from shop TrueWaveApparel For me, I think the Madewell jacket will hold up better over time, style-wise, since its plainer (no distressing). Ad from shop DreamboatAnnyVintage From shop CMsVintageshoppe, $88.00 While many of the items on Etsy are handmade, youll also find craft supplies, digital items, and more. After searching for a denim jacket for years, Im excited to finally have one that I want to reach for each day. Ad from shop driedflowersvintage To settle it once and for all, I ordered both to do a proper comparison of the Madewell&J Crew denim jackets. From shop SusOriginals, ad by MagicCarpetVintageUS Tracstore Fun but stylish! Learn more. From shop HudsonFlowVintage, ad by DavidsonStudio FREE shipping, ad by daisypickers From shop DreamboatAnnyVintage, ad by ToBeWornAgain cazadora vaquera hood azul mangas Crew version. Crew color and slight distressing, I want this purchase to be one I have for years to come. Gladifoundyou FREE shipping, ad by SusOriginals Ive been searching for the perfect denim jacket for years. Ad from shop ToBeWornAgain (15% off), ad by eldowho Ad from shop CompanyMan HandarbeitbyOMA From shop PinsByFerris, ad by 7thblockdesigns Ad from shop HandarbeitbyOMA Ive yet to wear it over a dress, but thats on my list to try! Madewell Denim Jacket in Pinter Wash (style #F0370) The tag has SP19, which indicates its part of the spring 2019 collection. While I was initially drawn to the J. Original Price $81.98 As it is, the XS fits on the smaller side. From shop driedflowersvintage, $39.00 jcrew Note: I purchased the above sneakers in store at New Balance Factory and there were no defects but the pair I ordered via Amazon came with yellow stains all over it. WildHorseSupplyCo Youll see ad results based on factors like relevancy, and the amount sellers pay per click. Ad from shop LorenaCheetahDesigns That said, in the two jackets I ordered, the J. FREE shipping, ad by CMsVintageshoppe (40% off), $695.00 Get free shipping on orders over $150 and you can use my, c/o Allbirds Tree Skippers in chalk I received these comfortable slip-on shoes a month ago as a gifted item from Allbirds. This tee is white with thin navy stripes and it has a relaxed fit. Yes! Captcha failed to load. Set where you live, what language you speak, and the currency you use. Original Price $80.00 From shop PaintedJackets4U, $100.00 FREE shipping, ad by Tracstore You can see how I wore it a few times in this post. This jacket is well made if youre looking for something different but timeless. jcrew FREE shipping, ad by TrueWaveApparel I also like to wear it with darker denim jeans and a sweater. Theres no way I could have worn an XXS in the denim jackets. From shop HotTopsDyes, Sale Price $35.99 Ad from shop BlackPearlVintage I noticed on the Nordstrom site the sleeve was listed as bracelet length. I noticed on the Nordstrom site the sleeve was listed as bracelet length. Does shopping on Etsy help support small businesses? From shop ToBeWornAgain, ad by FirstSightOfTheMoon Ad from shop HotTopsDyes Denim Jacket: J.Crew (20% off), ad by MarilynsClassicStore Ad from shop DCScoundrels I think they will wear in well over time. We've sent you an email to confirm your subscription. Ad from shop LilChickenVintage It wasnt the first time I received the wrong item in a J.Crew order but customer service emailed me a free return shipping label when I called. ludlow jcrew It hits higher on the hips so if you prefer a longer and more oversized fit then you may want to check out this jacket (review here) which comes in more colors. Ad from shop WildHorseSupplyCo Crew jacket are a shinier rose gold, which IMO look better. Etsy uses cookies and similar technologies to give you a better experience, enabling things like: Detailed information can be found in Etsys Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy and our Privacy Policy. FREE shipping, ad by LilChickenVintage Crew jackets except for the length. From shop FragilethingsbyJiroo, Sale Price $85.80 coats b1552 Ad from shop CMsVintageshoppe Ad from shop DavidsonStudio With powerful tools and services, along with expert support and education, we help creative entrepreneurs start, manage, and scale their businesses. Ad from shop bluegrassblondeshop From shop buildyourownart, $9.99 Great! jeans mercantile I found it interesting the dimensions were the same for both the Madewell and J. If youve followed my blog for a while, you know how often I talk about my love for denim jackets. Ad from shop SparklyLife FirstSightOfTheMoon Found something you love but want to make it even more uniquely you? From shop RecapVintageStudio, $140.00 FloralBanditStudio $72.00, $80.00 Both jackets are a little tight and stiff. $67.19, $111.99 (10% off), ad by RecapVintageStudio Sophia Vegan Leather Caged Convertible Crossbody, J.Crew Factory Flare crop white jean in signature stretch, Sofia Jeans by Sofia Vergara Womens Mid-Rise Shorts, New Balance Womens Dynasoft Pesu V1 Running Shoe. SusOriginals FREE shipping, ad by SparklyLife Ad from shop PinsByFerris Thank you for such a great comparison artie! J. There was a problem subscribing you to this newsletter. From shop HandarbeitbyOMA, $18.00 This is really getting into the details, but a few other random things. Crew: Regular $110, I paid $77 on sale at Nordstrom (also available at Nordstrom). Crew sweaters. FREE shipping, ad by GreenCanyonTradingCo FREE shipping, ad by buildyourownart slayvin HudsonFlowVintage Ad from shop Tracstore From shop FloralBanditStudio, $40.00 Personally, I preferred the extra length of the Madewell jacket. Click here to view a close up of the prints and textures Thank you Nip Tuck Swim for gifting me these beautiful swimsuits! (40% off), ad by bluegrassblondeshop After wearing both jackets around the house (and in the case of the Madewell jacket, outside of the house), I am keeping the Madewell denim jacket. A little background before I get into the details. From shop Tracstore, Sale Price $64.00 I have been looking for a denim jacket and it was difficult finding the perfect jacket. ad by PromotionsGeek FragilethingsbyJiroo From shop LorenaCheetahDesigns, $365.00 I accept that my email will be processed by FeedBurner and their privacy policy. CompanyMan Here is what the denim chore jacket looks like with white shorts. Find out more in our Cookies & Similar Technologies Policy. BlackPearlVintage Our global marketplace is a vibrant community of real people connecting over special goods. jcrew Ad from shop eldowho Ive bought and returned Madewell & J Crew denim jackets. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks! Ad from shop AirshipVintageCo This will differ depending on what options are available for the item. My usual size fit me well and the inseam hips above my ankles but the elder millennial in me still prefers skinny jeans. From shop DavidsonStudio, $54.00 Ad from shop GreenCanyonTradingCo FREE shipping, ad by driedflowersvintage I love both of these jackets but, I read your review & I went with the Madewell Jean jacket! In my experience, the color can vary even within the same style and wash. LilChickenVintage J. This didnt bother me as I dont see myself wearing it buttoned, but if you want to do so Id suggest going up two sizes. Its also home to a whole host of one-of-a-kind items made with love and extraordinary care. MagicCarpetVintageUS Depending on your height, this may be a deciding factor in the best fit for you. FREE shipping, ad by DreamboatAnnyVintage From shop FirstSightOfTheMoon, $34.00 Booties: Chloe(also here) DCScoundrels From shop CompanyMan, $68.00 Ad from shop MarilynsClassicStore Sweater: J.Crew I was comparing these and your input was helpful! Ad from shop GetThrifteeStore Ive been wearing the Madewell jacket around and its already started to loosen up. From shop slayvin, Sale Price $153.00 From shop GetThrifteeStore, Sale Price $72.00 PromotionsGeek On a side note, I was concerned about having enough outfits to wear with a denim jacket. I just noticed this $22 version from Walmart as well. Ad from shop HonorStudentVintage PaintedJackets4U J.Crew Factory Flare crop white jean in signature stretch, size 25 petite | Soludos Ibiza Sneaker (true to size) | Click here to view the clip from my try-on. Ad from shop MagicCarpetVintageUS From shop SparklyLife, $165.00 Some of the technologies we use are necessary for critical functions like security and site integrity, account authentication, security and privacy preferences, internal site usage and maintenance data, and to make the site work correctly for browsing and transactions. I should have ordered my usual size XXS for comparison since I think it would have been a better fit since size XS is loose allover including the sleeves. Fabricationss Click Buy it now or Add to cart and proceed to checkout. Im wearing my old favorite ecru skinny jeans above but I recently ordered these white mid-rise toothpick jeans in the 8 rise as seen on me here. GetThrifteeStore