Just put my Captains back in the box for return, failed eyelet on the upper left side of the left boot, eyelet completely failed, fully separated, theyre on their way back to the company, sorely disappointed as this was valued recommendation from Paul Stuart in New York City. Almost seems too perfect so I wonder if its corrected in any way. Chromexcel takes 28 days to make and is jam-packed with oils and greases, including beef tallow and beeswax, to imbue it with a particularly rich luster and depth of color. I think what youre looking for is the Natural color https://thursdayboots.com/products/mens-horween-natural-captain thats light but not as outdoorsy. Id definitely say the President would last longer, though. As such its a bit less versatile and dressy than the Captain, plus the Red Wing has thicker leather thats harder to break in. Doing additional research, Im finding some reviewers comment the Thursdays start to fall apart by year 3 and the insole makes it not worth resoling. For most of the leathers, applying Cobblers Choice Leather Conditioner every 6 to 12 months will help to hydrate the leather and improve its longevity. Yeah Im trying to do some cheaper boots, Ive got a few from LL Bean and Doc Martens and stuff coming out soon. So the right is just tight on the heel? How stiff is the toe on these boots? I love them both, and am slightly leaning towards the Thursday due the more fashionable, less clunky toe box. Loved your reviews on the Thursday Captain here and on YouTube. But now, thanks to your comparison with Thursday Boot Companys Captains you may have saved me $200. If you dont have a ton of boots, versatility is usually the most important factor for me. My choices are Black Captains and Brown President. Were told that adulthood starts at 18 or 21, but the older we get the more we realize that isnt true. It was more like a gamble for me. We finish school, we get jobs, maybe we wear a suit, maybe we dont. Ill take a good look at the welt as well because sometimes its uneven or poorly attached, like with the Indy: https://stridewise.com/alden-indy-403-boot-review/. Do you think they are good for everyday casual wear or too clunky? No quality control issues. Hi again Nick. Maturity comes slower than that and while this may sound silly, I think one of the marks of manhood is the first time you pay top dollar for a pair of quality, durable, head-turning boots. The Rugged & Resilient lines don't need conditioning, but its also a good idea to leave cedar shoe trees in the boots between wears to help maintain their shape and reduce moisture. Then dab some leather balm on the rag and work it into all their creases. I mentioned the nifty, studded rubber outsole and after a lot of wear I found it offered excellent traction, as expected. The Captain and practically all of their boots are $199 on both their official site and Amazon, a ridiculous steal for the quality and comfort. (But again, returns are free, so I wouldnt sweat it.). All my concerns melted away as the insole and midsole molded to the shape of my foot and ultimately left me feeling like I was wearing a sneaker. But in the Captain, Im a roomy 11.5 I suspect Id be a perfect 11.2 if they made it, which is exactly half a size down from my Brannock sizing. the two upper lace hooks really do a job when i lace them up. This leatherages just right: they got character, but not scars. What Exactly Is a Last, and Why Is It So Important? The wheeling issues are present but did not have the famous loose grain frequently reported on various forums. Is it possible to stretch that spot upwards? I plan on using them as an alternative to motorcycle boots and want to know if the toe is likely to get crushed due to the shift pedal. Hello , I just wanted to say I love my Thursday Tobacco Captains Boots. Thanks for commenting, David! (Thursday recommends. It depends on what environments youre planning to wear the boots in I guess, but you also have to take into account the Thursday is over a hundred dollars cheaper. Yeah if you take them to a cobbler I dont doubt they can stretch that out for you. I always want to buy boots thats not too causal and with some degree of water resistance that I can wear to office. Terrific! (I think.) Some are made with storm welts, but this is just another kind of Goodyear welt that's extra water resistant. This is the key to Thursdays famous comfort. For me I really value versatility and cost, and I think Thursday wins in that regard. Yeah that happens with most leather boots, Stephen! Enjoy! Men dont have a lot of rites of passage. I quite like the look + color combo of having both the Arizona Adobe and the Matte Black but want to make sure they would be appropriate with a dress shirt and khakis. Do they good enough to be kind of rain boots? Maybe consider Iron Rangers for that. Youve convinced me the Captain will fit the bill. I doubt they could be making much profit on these boots with their current prices, but as a consumer, I cant say Im complaining much. thursday boots captain brandy leather brown fits mens colour Ive been wearing size 11E Bates Chukkas for years, but Im thinking about switching to a Thursday President, but Im a little worried that I wont like them as much. I just want a boot I can dress up or down for travel so I can pack light. I havent tried the wingtip, they look pretty similar, just a different design on the toe and they look a bit dressier, so yeah I think they could work great when youre dressing up a bit. Congrats on the purchase. And I already own a Cognac Suede Scout. I just wrote a review of the vanguard! Its a great boot! I really appreciate your kind words about the site! I know you reviewed these quite some time ago now, but I have come across you youtube channel over the last month or so and I have really enjoyed your point of view. Funnily enough that kind of broguing when it originally was designed was for hunting in the British countryside and it was an absolute sin to wear any boots with broguing anywhere except for the outdoors. Definitely recommending your site to my friends. Cheers. Thursday Captain Boot: To Buy or Not to By? Thursday sells direct to consumer so its tough to try before you buy, but theyve got free shipping and returns anywhere in the U.S., so you shouldnt feel nervous about accidentally getting the wrong width or size. I also prefer its welt and sole. Haha I hope your boots are happy in the Philippines! Gotta say you were spot on! Sensing a gap in the market, the two launched the direct to consumer Thursday Boot Company with the goal of delivering the perfect hybrid boot at a low mark-up. And greetings from a tropical country! I got the terra cotta color thinking it was a bit warmer and more versatile turns out its lighter than I thought & Im thinking it might show scuffs easier than the brown. Im looking to have it fill the gap for dressier nights out with slacks, chinos or jeans. I think Thursdays are pretty durable but if youre willing to spend more money on casual boots, its true the Iron Rangers have thicker leather and are a bit more suited for super casual beaters. Wearing boots in the Philippines is considered odd however, that wont stop me from purchasing me next pair of Thursdays! A post shared by Stridewise (@stridewise), boots youd want for hiking or outdoor work, Thursday President Boot Review in Tobacco | Rugged and Resilient for $199, Are Reigning Champ Hoodies & Sweats Worth It? I just purchased the AE Higgins Mill boot in Brown, and the Thursday Captain in Brown. Hey Danny, glad you like the site, man. Can you just take them to any cobbler? I was considering buying the Thursday Explorer boot. The toe on the Captains isnt like an extra layer of leather, I wouldnt say its the best for protecting your toes. After finding and watching your youtube vids, I now have a pair of Captains (received last night), surprisingly purchased via Amazon.au Im in Sydney and some Edwin Selvedge jeans! Hey Michael, glad you like the site. In short, the leather upper and the sole, instead of being attached to each other, are attached to a strip of leather called a welt. My colleague wears these every day and they look great. I read your in depth, unbiased and thorough reviews of the Captain. Hi Nick. Cheers. What an excellent pair of boots! Red Wing Iron Ranger Vs. Wolverine 1000 Mile Which Is the Best Mens Boot? Its a bit too streamlined, not quite chunky enough. Theyre not shiny/chromey like Thursdays Brown, Black, and Natural, but I think so long as you pick a boot that doesnt have shiny nickel/silver looking eyelets, it can do fine with biz caszh. Thanks for the reply. A distinguishing feature is the toecap, but these arent your dads work boots. Haha a lot of guys cuss me out for costing them money. Hey Austin thanks for commenting man. Hey Brian, yeah I think the Thursday boots are solid in the rain, theyve got a 360-degree Goodyear welt so theyre very water resistant. The sole is secured to the boot with a classic 360-degree Goodyear welt, widely considered the best way to construct a boot. Ed this means the world to me, thanks so much for leaving a comment, and Im glad my words rung true for you! Im waiting for the Wingtip to become available again at Thursday. The 5 Best Leather Backpacks | Casual, Work, Best Value, Luxury, and More. Hey thanks for the comment Rob, sorry for the delay. Yeah I know leather is usually measured in ounces but its details that so few companies give out, I should make a habit of asking that number though. Then I watched your YouTube reviews of the Thursday President. Here are the most frequently asked questions from guys looking to buy Thursdays Captain boot. Do you have any brand recommendations, or am I being a wuss and push those trees in more. This does not cost you any extra money whatsoever, it just means the origin of the sale is tracked back to Stridewise. I do wear a lot of black but like the mild contrast of the dark brown. Sorry I missed your comment. Delighted they worked out for you. It cost a little more than other Thursday boots. Hey really happy the site could be useful, and its so cool to have a guy from Madagascar on the site! The fact that you wear all of the boots prior to reviewing them in order to give an more accurate and honest take on each product is very much appreciated. First I read your comparison between Iron Rangers and 1000 Miles and was going to pull the trigger on the 1000 Miles because of the Vibram outsole (Evans). How do you think the Thursday President compares to Bates Chukkas? Some people also arent impressed with the leather quality. Hey Nick, love your YouTube channel and all the reviews you put out. The sole is custom made by Thursday Boots, so it doesnt have the long-standing reputation of Vibram or Dainite, but after years of wear Id say the Thursdays perform just as effectively, holding up remarkably well in inclement weather. Theyd certainly be at home in a business casual environment, where theyd fit far more comfortably than Red Wings or Wolverines with their bulbous, informal toe boxes. If badass is what youre going for, Id go with black. If you can do that, and you get the rubber sole, theyre pretty good boots. Wore them today and no breaking in needed. Maybe you should have gone with the wide fit if youre EE. Im used to low/medium quality boots like Docs 1460s and Clarks desert boots so Im not going to judge them by Alden or Viberg standards. That there are a lot of subtle differences between boys and men but a well put together outfit with a sturdy pair of boots is one of the clearest signs that a guy cares how he is perceived by the world. Im sorry for the delay in responding, my blog hid your comment for some reason. Hi Nick, just wondering what kind of QC issues do you look for when purchasing a boot? I think that looks great adventuring or in casual environments, for the office, depending on where you work, I can see what you mean about them not being as dressy as the other leathers. Hey Arnab, thanks so much for the kind words! So my experience, limited as it is, was that I got better QC with the Thursdays. Hope you like em! After the outsole theres a cork-bed midsole, an anti-fatigue steel shank for arch support, soft leather lining on the inside, and their secret sauce: the Dura EVA comfort strip. Who Shouldnt Buy the Thursday Captain Boot? Its an understated boot, but the simplicity works in its favor. The Higgins Mill heel is lower, yes. Hey Nick, thanks for the review. That simply means that if you click the link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission for sending you there. Also managed to snag some AE Daltons on clearance + 20% 4th of a July sale + an additional 20% after complaining about some QC issues. Today its called a custom made Dura EVA comfort strip, which Thursday says has a bit more bounce than older models. Many customers who wear EE widths have had success ordering size larger to accommodate their feet for footwear in our Standard width. Both shoes are super versatile but Id agree the Thursday is a tad dressier.