As I wrote before, Google provides the email it finds in its databases, and it keeps capital/lowercase as it's in its DB. Also, I prefer using google_project_iam_member instead of google_project_iam_binding because when using google_project_iam_binding if there are any users or SAs created outside of Terraform bound to the same role, GCP would remove them on future runs (TF Apply). GPUs for ML, scientific computing, and 3D visualization. Rehost, replatform, rewrite your Oracle workloads. Task management service for asynchronous task execution. Fully managed solutions for the edge and data centers. You can define multiple google_project_iam_member blocks to attach multiple roles to a single user, or multiple users to a single role. the role's intended purpose, the date a role was created or modified, and any policy_data - (Required only by google_project_iam_policy) The google_iam_policy data source that represents Cloud-native wide-column database for large scale, low-latency workloads. Instead, grant the most Have a question about this project? This binding resource can be imported using the project_id and role, e.g. Cloud-based storage services for your business. The following did work for me: Another alternate would be to use a loop. Migration and AI tools to optimize the manufacturing value chain. Services for building and modernizing your data lake. I'll close this as a duplicate at this point as #4276 is the same issue. File storage that is highly scalable and secure. Generate instant insights from data at any scale with a serverless, fully managed analytics platform that significantly simplifies analytics. Data from Google, public, and commercial providers to enrich your analytics and AI initiatives. The API was returning the error googleapi: Error 400: Role roles/myCustomRole is not supported for this resource., badRequest when trying to create the google_project_iam_member. Identity and Access Management (IAM) with Google Cloud IAM basic and predefined roles reference - Google Cloud In addition to the basic roles, IAM provides additional Looking at the debug log, I would guess that this is causing the failure: Terraform receives an IAM policy that has a series of members named user: from the API. Serverless change data capture and replication service. If an issue is assigned to the "modular-magician" user, it is either in the process of being autogenerated, or is planned to be autogenerated soon. The nature of simulating nature: A Q&A with IBM Quantum researcher Dr. Jamie We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Serverless application platform for apps and back ends. Thanks @intotecho, Thanks for your answer. Accelerate business recovery and ensure a better future with solutions that enable hybrid and multi-cloud, generate intelligent insights, and keep your workers connected. Custom roles can contain up to 3,000 permissions. modify all projects and other resources under that organization. The policy will be You can create up to 300 organization-level Not Image by PublicDomainPictures from Pixabay, Create Multiple Resources at Once With Terraform for_each, How to use Google asymmetric KMS keys to encrypt given secrets in Terraform. organization level or the project level. Application error identification and analysis. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. Yes, in fact, it can go all the way up if more people vote for this rather than the accepted answer. setIamPolicy permission. App migration to the cloud for low-cost refresh cycles. How do I align things in the following tabular environment? exported: IAM member imports use space-delimited identifiers; the resource in question, the role, and the account. Basic roles are highly permissive roles that existed prior to the introduction of IAM. I suspect that there is something strange happening with the IAM policy for your existing project. you can disable the role. to update the organization's metadata. The most Infrastructure and application health with rich metrics. It could possibly be related to changes in the IAM API that happened around the filing date of this issue. an existing custom role. Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! Alternatively, if you have a single role with multiple members, you could use google_project_iam_binding with the caveat that Terraform will remove the role from any users not present in that config. Run on the cleanest cloud in the industry. Platform for creating functions that respond to cloud events. recommended for production use. An initiative to ensure that global businesses have more seamless access and insights into the data required for digital transformation. Specifically, I see that we attempt to reflect a deleted IAM principle back in the setPolicy response. Tools and resources for adopting SRE in your org. Recovering from a blunder I made while emailing a professor. Run the gcloud iam roles describe Except as otherwise noted, the content of this page is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License, and code samples are licensed under the Apache 2.0 License. permission. rev2023.3.3.43278. Staging Ground Beta 1 Recap, and Reviewers needed for Beta 2, GCP IAM roles for sonatype-nexus-community/nexus-blobstore-google-cloud, Bucket query permission denied in GCP despite service-account having the Owner role, Clarification on "list" IAM permission in GCP, Want to assign multiple Google cloud IAM roles to a service account via terraform, GCP predefines IAM roles per Project and Terraform, Terraform google_project_iam_binding deletes GCP compute engine default service account from IAM principals, gcp giving it roles iam roles to configure the policiy. In Dungeon World, is the Bard's Arcane Art subject to the same failure outcomes as other spells? Please fix. @michyliao that looks like a different issue. As a result, if you grant, permissions that are supported in custom The IAM role are strange at the beginning. for a custom role is 64 KB. Role description: The role description is an optional field where you can The permission is fully supported in custom roles. Cloud Identity and Access Management Overview, Granting, Changing, and Revoking Access to Project Members, Open the console left side menu and select. This helps our maintainers find and focus on the active issues. google_project_iam_policy: Authoritative. I'm not going to explain these in detail. Read what industry analysts say about us. End-to-end migration program to simplify your path to the cloud. viewing (but not modifying) existing resources or data. Rapid Assessment & Migration Program (RAMP). It's not recommended to use google_project_iam_policy with your provider project By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. How to name your google project IAM resources in Terraform You cannot grant custom roles on other projects or organizations, Role titles can be up to 100 bytes long and Playbook automation, case management, and integrated threat intelligence. ASIC designed to run ML inference and AI at the edge. Configure NFS with the CLI. Fully managed, PostgreSQL-compatible database for demanding enterprise workloads. This may include design, build, testing against requirements, operational assessment and implementation activities. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. If you prefer the non-authoritative nature of memberyou can still have a single resource manage multiple members/roles using a loop. help to ensure that the principals in your organization have only the Options for running SQL Server virtual machines on Google Cloud. Encrypt data in use with Confidential VMs. Create and manage Google groups in the Google Cloud console, Obtain short-lived credentials for workforce identity federation, Manage workforce identity pools and providers, Delete workforce identity federation users and their data, Set up user access to console (federated), Best practices for using service accounts, Best practices for using service accounts in deployment pipelines, Create and manage short-lived credentials, Create short-lived credentials for a service account, Create short-lived credentials for multiple service accounts, Restrict a credential's Cloud Storage permissions, Migrate to the Service Account Credentials API, Federate identities for external workloads, Manage workload identity pools and providers, Best practices for using workload identity federation, Best practices for managing service account keys, Use Deployment Manager to maintain custom roles, Test permissions for custom user interfaces, Use IAM to help prevent exfiltration from data pipelines, Optimize IAM policies by using Policy Intelligence tools, Help secure IAM using VPC Service Controls, Example logs for workforce identity federation, Example logs for workload identity federation, Tools to understand service account usage, Monitor usage patterns for service accounts and keys, Troubleshoot "withcond" in policies and role bindings, Troubleshoot workload identity federation, All Identity and Access Management code samples, Migrate from PaaS: Cloud Foundry, Openshift, Save money with our transparent approach to pricing. It's possible humans get an inherited viewer role from a folder or the org itself, but assigning multiple roles using the google_project_iam_member is a much much better way and how 95% of the permissions are done with TF in GCP. If you need to use a @slevenick I had never attempted this particular role assignment (roles/cloudsql.client) using a resource "google_project_iam_binding" "" {} block before on any version, but I do have a project that assigns a role which currently uses provider.google v2.16.0. Editor role includes the permissions in the Viewer role. Is there a proper earth ground point in this switch box? Sometimes you want your policy to stomp on any changes made by others. Not the answer you're looking for? predefined roles that give granular access to specific Google Cloud Google Cloud's pay-as-you-go pricing offers automatic savings based on monthly usage and discounted rates for prepaid resources. Extract signals from your security telemetry to find threats instantly. Share Improve this answer Follow answered May 17, 2022 at 4:49 Will Beebe 11 1 Debug Logs, terraform apply -target=module.booklawyer.module.etl.google_project_iam_binding.sql_client. roles always have the ETag AA==. Streaming analytics for stream and batch processing. For instance if there is a user admin and a service account with the same name, use user_admin and service_account_admin. Fully managed database for MySQL, PostgreSQL, and SQL Server. Fully managed open source databases with enterprise-grade support. To disable the role, change its launch stage to The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: google_project_iam_member is used to define a single user:role pairing. and write it. Real-time insights from unstructured medical text. predefined roles, the ID is the same as the role name. These roles are created and maintained by Google. This includes updating roles You And you have found that removing the user with capital letters allows you to apply the binding? GCP IAM question - Google - HashiCorp Discuss custom roles in your organization. Anyone with owner-level permissions, such as a project creator, can add and remove other project members and edit their permissions settings. Accelerate startup and SMB growth with tailored solutions and programs. As I wrote before, I tried to re-add the user in low case letters, but Google added it again with capital ones like it originally was (and you saw this behavior when you tried to add a user with capital letters). It can be up to Build better SaaS products, scale efficiently, and grow your business. Custom roles are user-defined, and allow you to bundle one or more supported Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. In addition to the arguments listed above, the following computed attributes are Sets the IAM policy for the project and replaces any existing policy already attached. This policy resource can be imported using the project_id. Roles and permissions | IAM Documentation | Google Cloud API management, development, and security platform. You can delete a custom Descriptions can be up to To determine if a permission is included in a basic, predefined, or custom role, @slevenick Continuous integration and continuous delivery platform. I have a resource "google_project_iam_custom_role", a data "google_iam_policy" (not certain this is required), and a resource "google_project_iam_member". cbse government schools in navi mumbai Put your data to work with Data Science on Google Cloud. Looking at the logs, I suspect the issue is related to deleted IAM principles. To make sure your custom roles are effective, you can create custom roles based But I am facing another error while assigning this. Hi @slevenick Proceed with caution. using unique and descriptive titles to better distinguish your roles. Tools for managing, processing, and transforming biomedical data. Getting the role metadata. So, which resource do you use in practice? By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. The log (attached, with some security related masking) is for google-beta but it fails the same way for google too. is ready for widespread use. I have created a user with capital letters, but the IAM console only finds it as lowercase, which doesn't cause any issues. manage your custom roles. Commit code to GitHub and submit a Pull Request (PR) You'll execute all the above steps by adding a new feature to the Google Cloud Storage CFT module. resource's descendants. Ensure your business continuity needs are met. Automatic cloud resource optimization and increased security. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. I believe that the issue happens when attempting to add a role to a new service account (existing policy), you have to first fetch the policy which includes the user with the capital letter, then append to it and apply it. lowercase alphanumeric characters, underscores, and periods. Reference templates for Deployment Manager and Terraform. Components for migrating VMs into system containers on GKE. Do roots of these polynomials approach the negative of the Euler-Mascheroni constant? Run and write Spark where you need it, serverless and integrated. that is, the Owner role includes the permissions in the Editor role, and the Terraform GCP Assign IAM roles to service account, cloud.google.com/resource-manager/reference/rest/v1/projects/, How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability. might notice that a predefined role was updated with permissions to use a new Unify data across your organization with an open and simplified approach to data-driven transformation that is unmatched for speed, scale, and security with AI built-in. Naming Terraform resources is quite a challenge. From the project list, choose the project that you want to add a member to. Fully managed environment for running containerized apps. Platform for defending against threats to your Google Cloud assets. What's the most weird in this situation is that I can't add that user back with low case letters. I understand that RFC defines email addresses as case insensitive. Commit code to GitHub and submit a Pull Request (PR) You'll execute all the above steps by adding a new feature to the Google Cloud Storage CFT module. Above the list on the right, click Change role . Accelerate development of AI for medical imaging by making imaging data accessible, interoperable, and useful. Grow your startup and solve your toughest challenges using Googles proven technology. Therefore, we recommend to use the resource google_project_iam_member to define the google IAM policies in your project. Granting the Owner role at the organization level doesn't allow you Be careful! Solution for improving end-to-end software supply chain security. Reduce cost, increase operational agility, and capture new market opportunities. Solutions for modernizing your BI stack and creating rich data experiences. Avoid using these roles if possible, because they include a wide range of permissions across all Google Cloud services. API - Wikipedia yes, to my luck the problem user actually does not use gcp currently, so I could temporary remove it. The same problem may occurs to a lesser extend with the google_project_iam_binding. disabling a custom role. You can send it to my github username @google.com. Select a trigger, such as Security Rating Summary. provide additional information about a role. User creation is not actually relevant to the case. If you can point me to the code where this is done I can try to replicate it using gcloud CLI, and see if its an SKD issue or implementation issue (usually the SDK will make fixes to it before applying it). Thanks! Manage project members or change project ownership - API Console Help Manage project members or change project ownership Anyone with owner-level permissions, such as a project. A role contains a set of permissions that allows you to perform specific actions on. Hey @akrasnov-drv sorry that this caused issues for you. getIamPolicy permission for that service and resource type, in addition to the For custom roles, the Assign roles to a group's members - Google Workspace Admin Help I think the right fix is likely to filter out deleted principles when sending the IAM policy back. It will help me track down what exactly about these users is causing the issue. You can't reuse a Likely it's old. organization, you must use the Google Cloud console, not the You should only allow a small number of highly trusted principals to Note that custom roles must be of the format Were you able to successfully apply this config with versions of the provider after 2.12.0 prior to filing this issue? I don't know if you can register new Google user with capital letters in email now, but it was definitely possible in the past. How to attach multiple IAM policies to IAM roles using Terraform? Solutions for CPG digital transformation and brand growth. Responsible for completing assigned work on the project during the execute phase. If you haven't updated the package database recently, update it now: sudo apt update. How can this new ban on drag possibly be considered constitutional? google_project_iam_member to define a single role binding for a single principal. Don't know if that makes a difference. If I add a user with a capital letter, it behaves the same way as in all of the cases described here, where Terraform lowercases any capital letters coming from the API, but in all of my cases the API accepts the lowercase version. Platform for modernizing existing apps and building new ones. Virtual machines running in Googles data center. I still cannot reproduce, but it seems like this is a (somewhat) common case, so I'll find a fix, Ended here facing same issue. Detect, investigate, and respond to online threats to help protect your business. Can you file a separate issue with debug logs included? Logs Viewer roles on a project, and also have the Pub/Sub Publisher role on a Integration that provides a serverless development platform on GKE. Unified platform for IT admins to manage user devices and apps. AI model for speaking with customers and assisting human agents. Processes and resources for implementing DevOps in your org. Explore benefits of working with a partner. google_project_iam_member is used to define a single user:role pairing. What is the point of Thrower's Bandolier? Select. What I'm trying to figure out is if this broke with the 2.13.0 release or if the combination of 2.13.0+ and the API changes that happened around Dec 6th are causing it. Stay in the know and become an innovator. Looks like besides the order, the sent data is exactly the same besides the etag (2.12.0 json & 2.20.1 json) which I'm not sure whether that's supposed to change. any predefined roles that your custom role is based on in the custom role's To learn how to create a custom role based on a predefined role, see Permissions for read-only actions that do not affect state, such as from anyone without organization-level access to the project. I've been able to consistently reproduce it on my project, here are the debug logs. Another common launch stage is DISABLED. roles. Other members for the role for the project are preserved. Service to prepare data for analysis and machine learning. checking those predefined roles for permission changes. Deploy ready-to-go solutions in a few clicks. description field. Furthermore, it is highly unlikely that a principal will only need to be bound to a single role. Migrate and manage enterprise data with security, reliability, high availability, and fully managed data services. Block storage that is locally attached for high-performance needs. Tools for easily optimizing performance, security, and cost. is, each Google Cloud service has an associated permission for each launch stages are informational; they help you keep track of whether each role To learn how to create a custom role based on a predefined role, see Creating When you assign a role to a project member, you grant that project member all the permissions that the role contains. custom roles. Refer to the permissions change log to Sign in Here is some sample code using a count loop. API-first integration to connect existing data and applications. Can I have one of you @akrasnov-drv or @jjorissen52 send me the actual email that is causing the problems? If an issue is assigned to a user, that user is claiming responsibility for the issue. google_project_iam_member/google_project_iam_binding Fails for roles How can I assign multiple roles against a single service account? io/minio/minio latest 8dbf9ff992d5 30 hours ago 183 MB. It's possible humans get an inherited viewer role from a folder or the org itself, but assigning multiple roles using the google_project_iam_member is a much much better way and how 95% of the permissions are done with TF in GCP. I'm still having trouble reproducing this issue, and I believe that there is something strange going on with the particular emails being used here as emails are not handled case sensitively by the API. Editing an existing custom role. Choose a topic for information on managing project members. I believe this is an unrelated issue, but it presents with the same (not very helpful) error message. Automated tools and prescriptive guidance for moving your mainframe apps to the cloud. As you know, Google IAM resources in Terraform come in three flavors: This IAM policy for a Google project is a singleton. See Granting, changing, and revoking Each of these resources serves a different use case: Note: google_project_iam_policy cannot be used in conjunction with google_project_iam_binding and google_project_iam_member or they will fight over what your policy should be. @jjorissen52 That is odd. Managed and secure development environments in the cloud. Tracking these changes The permission is not supported in custom roles. It is not convenient to manage multiple roles and members.by the way.What is "project id"? You can use this information to inform how you create and It's the same thing with you use the gcloud command, you can add only 1 role at the time on a list of email. Image by PublicDomainPictures from Pixabay by Mark van Holsteijn Required for google_project_iam_policy - you must explicitly set the project, and it The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: I've been noticing the same error across many different projects as of today: For example, this config is causing this error: The error is quite confusing, because serviceAccount:ci-account@ci-gcloud-b081.iam.gserviceaccount.com looks valid as an IAM member to me. the project. Tools for easily managing performance, security, and cost. Tools and guidance for effective GKE management and monitoring. I was just experiencing what seems like a related issue to this and #4276 and was able to solve it. Already on GitHub? help you identify the role: Role ID: The role ID is a unique identifier for the role. ID is everything after roles/ in the role name. That's very unusual. Each permission Testing and deploying. gcloud CLI. roles, choose the most appropriate predefined roles. IAM Identities (users, user groups, and roles) - AWS Identity and Solution for running build steps in a Docker container. If you use policies it will be similar to how wine is made, it will be a stomping party! Fully managed, native VMware Cloud Foundation software stack. The Google Cloud console does this automatically when you Permissions allow Reimagine your operations and unlock new opportunities. The name for a google_project_iam_member is the name of the principal, converted to snake case. Please let me know if you encounter the same issue with that version, but I'll close this until then. Could you try either using the console or gcloud to remove these members, or using a project_iam_policy which is authoritative? Select a role. Google: google_project_iam - Terraform by HashiCorp